Website Aged Care Justice
The Royal Commission into Aged Care Quality and Safety found an overuse of restrictive practices in aged care and recommended urgent legislative reforms.
Restrictive practices involve limiting an individual’s freedom to control their behaviour, and can include physical restraint, the use of psychoactive medications, or secluding an individual in a room where they cannot leave or are led to believe they cannot leave.
To clarify who can decide on the use of a restrictive practice in residential aged care in Victoria, the State Government introduced the Aged Care Restrictive Practices Substitute Decision-maker Act(SDM Act), which commenced on 1 July 2025.
The SDM Act provides a hierarchy of persons who can make decisions on behalf of an aged care resident in relation to the use of a restrictive practice when the aged care resident does not have decision-making capacity.
Aged Care Justice (ACJ) has created Fact Sheets for the public and the legal community to increase understanding of the new requirements. Click here to view. This project received funding through the Victorian Legal Services Board Grants Program.
Under the Commonwealth aged care legislation, residential aged care providers must obtain informed consent to a restrictive practice before its use. The SDM Act was required as Enduring Powers of Attorney or Medical Treatment Decision Maker appointments in Victoria do not cover restrictive practices.
“These reforms were urgently required to stop the confusion on who can provide or withhold consent to the use of a restrictive practice. This is a human rights issue, and further reforms are needed, such as guidelines to assist a substitute decision maker on the considerations in making these difficult decisions”, says ACJ CEO and Solicitor, Anna Willis.
The order of substitute decision makers set out by the SDM Act is (1) a person nominated by the aged care resident (2) a temporary appointment if there is no nomination, (3) appointment by application to the Victorian Civil Administration Tribunal (VCAT), and (4) application by the aged care provider for VCAT to decide on the use of a restrictive practice.
ACJ has created three fact Sheets, two for the general public and one for the legal community. The Fact Sheet for the public, ‘Who can make decisions on the use of restrictive practices in residential aged care in Victoria?’ explains the hierarchy and the process to be followed for nominations or appointments. The Order of Restrictive Practice Substitute Decision Makers is a visual summary of the hierarchy for the public. The Fact Sheet for the Legal Community provides a more detailed guide on the provisions of the SDM Act to assist the legal sector.
“Many people believe that because you are a resident’s next of kin, or spouse, or EPOA, that you can make decisions regarding their aged care practices” warns ACJ Chair and Dentons Partner, Sue Williamson.
“The reality is that substitute decision making is a complicated area of law, and different roles have different responsibilities. Decision-making capacity can also fluctuate, and the law requires residents to be supported to make their own decisions when they are able to. Our Fact Sheets aim to increase community understanding and safeguard older Australians’ rights”, says Williamson.
If you would like more information, an interview, or to collaborate with Aged Care Justice on this important issue, please contact Katrina Ryan at katrinaryan@agedcarejustice.org.au or 0477 359 029, or Anna Willis at annawillis@agedcarejustice.org.au or 0417 234 415.
About Aged Care Justice:
Aged Care Justice Inc. (ACJ) is a registered charity supporting Australians living in Residential aged care or receiving home care by providing access to legal services, educational material on aged care rights, and lobbying for sector reform. ACJ was formed in 2020 by senior legal and clinical professionals to ensure all Australians receive quality aged care services and are treated with dignity and respect. When a person contacts ACJ, we listen to their issue and connect them with a lawyer with experience in aged care issues who will provide a free legal consultation anywhere in Australia. Our panel of firms have agreed to identify the most efficient and economical way to proceed after the initial consultation, which may include pro bono assistance.
Contact Aged Care Justice if you would like a free legal consultation:
Email: info@agedcarejustice.org.au
Phone: 0417 234 415
Website: www.agedcarejustice.org.au
